doc 02341 1

← Back to Archive
Page 1
ee.
SPACEPORT
BoardofCountyCommissionersContact:JohnSimpson
P.O.Box99/200East4"Street912-467-2754(cell)
Woodbine,Georgia31569jsimpson@capitolresourcesllc.com
FORIMMEDIATERELEASE
CamdenCountyReleasesITARCompliantFlight
SafetyAnalysisforSpaceportCamden
WOODBINE,Ga.October3,2019TheCamdenCountyBoardofCommissioners
——
hasbeenworkingdiligentlytodetermineawaytoincreasetransparencyabouttheproject’s
licensinginformationwithoutcomplicatingtheagency’songoingrevieworreleasingsensitiveor
export-controlledinformationthatcannotlawfullybesharedwiththepublic.Pursuanttothose
goals,theCountyinitiatedthedevelopmentofapubliclyreleasablereport,preparedbyThe
AerospaceCorporation,thatdescribestheproject’sflightsafetyanalysis.
“WeheardfromCamdenCountyresidentsthattheywantedtobetterunderstandhowSpaceport
CamdencouldsatisfytheFAA’ssafetycriteria.ThisreportshowsthatSpaceportCamdencannot
notonlymeetthoserequirements,butsignificantlyexceedsthem,”saidBoardofCounty
CommissionChairman,JimmyStarline.
CertaindatausedinaflightsafetyanalysisarecontrolledfrompublicreleasebytheInternational
TrafficinArmsRegulations(ITAR),theMissileTechnologyControlRegime(MTCR)andother
statutes.Priortothereleaseofreport,CamdenCountyreceivedguidancefromtheDepartment
ofDefenseOfficeofPrepublicationandSecurityReviewtocleartheseissues.
TheAerospaceCorporationisanonprofitcorporationthatoperatesaFederallyFundedResearch
andDevelopmentCenterfortheUnitedStatesAirForceandtheintelligencecommunityand
supportsallnationalsecurityspaceprograms.“TheAerospaceCorporationisthegoldstandard
forflightsafetyanalysis,”saidCommissionVice-Chairman,GaryBlount.“Theirworkforthe
DepartmentofDefenseandNASAmakesomeoftheirmethodologiesasensitivenationalsecurity
issuebuttheyarethebestatwhattheydo.|amgladwewereabletoclearthenationalsecurity
hurdlesandmakethisinformationavailabletothepublic.”
Therearetwoprimaryriskfactorsthatareanalyzedinaflightsafetyanalysis:collectiverisktoall
thepopulationinthevicinityofalaunch,alsoreferredtoasexpectedcasualty(E.),andindividual
risk(Pina)whichistherisktoanyonepersoninagovernmentdefinedarea(gridsquare).Pingis
nottypicallyrequiredforaspaceportlicenseapplicationbutisrequiredforeverylaunchlicense
issuedforanactuallaunch.
“LaunchingTomorrow’sFutureToday®”
STEVEL.HOWARDJOHNS.MYERS
CountyAdministratorCountyAttorney
LANNIEBRANTCHUCKCLARKJIMMYSTARLINEGARYBLOUNTBENCASEY
Commissioner,District1Commissioner,District2Commissioner,District3Commissioner,District4Commissioner,District5
Page 2
PressRelease:CamdenCountyReleasesTTARCompliantFlightSafetyAnalysisforSpaceportCamdenPage2of4
Thecollectiveriskisquantifiedintermsoftheexpectednumberofcasualtiesforalaunchmission,
givencertainassumptionsrelatedtothetypeofrocket,thetrajectoryflown,assumedweather
andwinds,anticipated/potentialpopulationinthevicinity,andmanyotherfactors,asprovided
byFAAregulationsandgenerallypracticedintheindustry.Hundredsofthousandsoflaunch
failuresaremodeledaspartoftheflightsafetyanalysistocalculatethevariousriskprobabilities.
Aconcertedeffortwasmadetoaccuratelyandconservativelymodelthedesignfeaturesofthe
representativerocketsandthepopulationinthespaceportvicinity.Inadditiontothelocalcensus
dataandspecificglobalpopulationdensitydatabasesrequiredtobeusedbyfederalregulation,
CamdenCountyadded380campers,visitorsandstafftoCumberlandIsland(Cl),reflectingvery
conservative(andunlikely)assumptionsthateverycampgroundwasfilledtocapacity,theisland
containedthemaximumnumberofvisitors(300)allowedbylaw,andtheislandanditsfacilities
werefullystaffed.Further,5350launchspectatorswereaddedtoviewinglocationsinandaround
CamdenCounty.Finally,everyhabitablestructureonLittleCumberlandIsland(LCI)andnorth
Clneartheflighttrajectorywasassumedtobeoccupiedbyavaryingnumberofpersons.Itwas
furtherassumedthateverypopulationgroupinthedatabasesusedfortheanalysis,andcitizens
ofCamdenCounty,includingtheadditionalpopulationsjustdescribed,werealloutsideand
unsheltered,foreverylaunchfailuremodeledintheanalysis.Additionally,thelaunchvehiclewas
assumedtohavea5%failureprobabilityforeachstageofflight(ascent,secondstagetoorbit
andfirststagelandingreturn,therefore15%totalfailurerate).Thistotalfailurerateassumption
is50%higherthantheraterequiredbyFAAregulations.
TheFAAspecifiestheacceptablelevelofcumulativeriskforalaunchtobelessthan1in10,000
casualties(1x10)toonesignificantfigure.ThismeansthatestimatesofE.areeitherrounded
downoruptoonesignificantfigurewhenevaluated.Therefore,anestimatedE,of1.49per10,000
passestheFAArequirement.TheSpaceportCamdenflightsafetyanalysisofthemedium-large
launcher’s100-degreereferencetrajectorydemonstratesthatithaslessthan1.49expected
casualtiesin10,000overallphasesofflightassumingupto5personsperhabitablestructureon
LCIandnorthCl,andthenumerousothervisitorsandviewersintheCamdenregion.Ifonlythe
outboundlaunchoperation(combined1ststageand2ndstage,withnofirststagereturntolanding
pad)isconsidered,thenE,remainlessthan1.49in10,000evenassuming10personsperLCI/Cl
habitablestructureandtheadditionalpopulations.Theresultsareshowninthetablebelow.
“LaunchingTomorrow’sFutureToday®”
STEVEL.HOWARDJOHNS.MYERS
CountyAdministratorCountyAttorney
LANNIEBRANTCHUCKCLARKJIMMYSTARLINEGARYBLOUNTBENCASEY
Commissioner,District1Commissioner,District2Commissioner,District3Commissioner,District4Commissioner,District5
Page 3
PressRelease:CamdenCountyReleasesITARComphantFightSafetyAnalysisforSpaceportCamdenPage3of4
Table5.SpaceportCamdenMedium-LargeEcResults(x10*)
Personsper
CI/LCIClCampersLaunchStage1Stage1LaunchTotalAll
Structure&VisitorsViewersAscentReturnStage2Only*Phases
0000.0130.0010.010.020.02
0053500.0360.020.010.050.07
038000.0530.170.010.060.23
2000.270.180.010.280.46
238053500.360.370.010.370.74**
a38053500.610.550.010.621.17
538053500.770.640.010.781.42
638053500.900.730.010.911.64
838053501.170.910.011.182.09
1038053501.441.090.011.452.54
*NoStage1Return
**ReferenceCase
AsanadditionalconsiderationforoperationsatSpaceportCamden,anassessmentofasmall
launchvehiclewasalsoperformed.Noreturnflightwasmodeledasallcurrentsmalllaunch
vehiclesareexpendable,buttheanalysisincludedahigher10%failureprobabilityperstageof
flight.Resultsindicatethatevenwhenassumingthelargestsurroundingpopulationscenario
outlinedearlier,andupto40peopleperLCI/Clhabitablestructuretheexpectedcasualtyremains
lessthantheFAArequirementof1.49in10,000.
Table7.SmallLaunchVehicleRiskResults
CamdenCountywithAddedPopulationExpectedCasualty(/10,000)
Personsper
CI/LCIClCampersLaunch
Structure&VisitorsViewersStage1Stage2Total
0000.0010.010.01
0053500.0140.010.02
038000.0160.010.03
2000.0680.010.08
238053500.0980.010.11
1038053500.370.010.38
2038053500.710.010.72
4038053501.390.011.40
100-degreeazimuthtrajectoryIndividualrisk=0.10x10%
“LaunchingTomorrow’sFutureToday®”
STEVEL.HOWARDJOHNS.MYERS
CountyAdministratorCountyAttorney
LANNIEBRANTCHUCKCLARKJIMMYSTARLINEGARYBLOUNTBENCASEY
Commissioner,District1Commissioner,District2Commissioner,District3Commissioner,District4Commissioner,District5
Page 4
PressRelease:CamdenCountyReleasesITARCompliantFightSafetyAnalysisforSpaceportCamdenPage4of4
WhiletypicallynotrequiredforaLaunchSiteOperatorLicense(LSOL)application,The
AerospaceCorporationcalculatedtheIndividualRisk(Ping)resultsforthelargestrocketproposed
forSpaceportCamden,amedium-largelaunchvehicle.TheFAArequirementforPingislessthan
1inamilliontoonesignificantfigure(solessthan1.49permillion).ThisFAArequirementistwo
ordersofmagnitudemorestringentthatthecumulativerisk(E.)requirementdiscussedearlier.
Theindividualriskforarepresentativemedium-largelauncheron100-degreeazimuthtrajectory
fromSpaceportCamdenwascalculatedtobe0.50permilliononascent(launch)and0.66per
milliononreturn(landing)flight.
“CamdenCountyspentaconsiderableamountoftimeandresourcestomakethisFlightSafety
Analysisavailabletothepublic.Thereportprovesdefinitivelythatwecanlaunchawiderange
oflaunchvehiclesfromSpaceportCamdenwithmorethan2000peopleonLittleCumberland
IslandandCumberlandIsland,”addedChairmanStarline.
AfullversionofTheAerospaceCorporationFlightSafetyAnalysisisavailableonlineat:
https://issuu.com/camdencountyboc/docs/vtr-2019-01516?fr=sZjAxXMDMZODE2Ng.
MoreaboutSpaceportCamden:OurVisionistodevelopasuccessfulworldclassspaceportthroughapublic-
privatepartnershipthatestablishesCamdenCountyastheCommercialSpaceCenteroftheUnitedStates.OurMission
istocreatethepremierspaceportstrategicallypositionedtoprovideeconomicdiversitywithacompetitiveadvantage
forthespacesector,CamdenCounty,theStateofGeorgiaandtheUnitedStatesofAmerica.Formoreinformation,
pleaseviewourwebsiteatwww.SpaceportCamden.us.
MoreaboutTheAerospaceCorporation:TheAerospaceCorporationisanationalnonprofitcorporationthat
operatesafederallyfundedresearchanddevelopmentcenterandhasapproximately4,000employees.Withmajor
locationsinElSegundo,Calif.,Albuquerque,N.M.,ColoradoSprings,Colo.,andtheWashington,D.C.,region,
Aerospaceaddressescomplexproblemsacrossthespaceenterpriseandotherareasofnationalsignificancethrough
agility,innovation,andobjectivetechnicalleadership.Formoreinformation,visitwww.aerospace.org,or
follow@AerospaceCorponTwitter.
Finduson:
FA-
camdenspaceportSpaceportCamden
HHH
“LaunchingTomorrow’sFutureToday®”
STEVEL.HOWARDJOHNS.MYERS
CountyAdministratorCountyAttorney
LANNIEBRANTCHUCKCLARKJIMMYSTARLINEGARYBLOUNTBENCASEY
Commissioner,District1Commissioner,District2Commissioner,District3Commissioner,District4Commissioner,District5